| Name | Year | Position |
| Chris Wegener | 1983 | 1st Base |
| Garth Brittenham | 1984 | Pitcher |
| Bryan Kuehne | 1985 | Outfielder |
| Greg Chapie | 1986 | Shortstop |
| Rolly Noe | 1987 | 2nd Base |
| Rolly Noe | 1988 | Shortstop |
| Rolly Noe | 1989 | Shortstop |
| Todd Hiler | 1990 | 2nd Base |
| Dennis McBride | 1991 | 2nd Base |
| Dennis McBride | 1992 | 2nd Base |
| Cory Sturgess | 1993 | 2nd Base |
| Mike Villano | 1994 | Catcher |
| Cory Sturgess | 1995 | 2nd Base |
| John Sullivan | 1996 | 1st Base |
| Heath Fowler | 1997 | Catcher |
| Bryan Dole | 1998 | 1st Base |
| Kraig Enders | 1999 | Shortstop |
| Kraig Enders | 2000 | Shortstop |
| Jason Valenzuela | 2000 | 2nd Base |
| Adam Ruffner | 2001 | Pitcher/Outfielder |
| Adam Piggott | 2002 | 1st Base |
| Scott Corby | 2003 | Pitcher |
| Adam Piggott | 2004 | 1st Base |
| Dan Jones | 2005 | 1st Base |
| Reed Welker | 2006 | Outfielder |
| Scott Schalff | 2007 | Pitcher |
| Reed Welker | 2008 | Outfielder |
| Ryan Webber | 2009 | Catcher |
| Kevin Dore | 2010 | 2nd Base |
| Kyle O'Boyle | 2011 | Outfielder |
| 2012 | ||
| Brad Schalk | 2013 | Outfielder |
| Jordan Swiss | 2019 | 3rd Base |